You did not ask me a single question in your reply to me, so please point out what exact questions you have for me and I will answer them.I'm not asking for kitten mittens. I'm asking you to explain where I'm wrong with logical reasoning and deduction, or present evidence of the same. It's not hard.
You are not in any position here to ask me what I think is wrong. YOU are the one coming here and saying this system is wrong and should be completely scrapped and removed. Yet you have failed to provide any of what you ask of me.
If this system that decides at what point a ship is "dead" is wrong, I expect you to prove that and provide both logical reasoning WHY and what methods could be provided to replace it.
Better yet the only part of this system you have been bitching about is boarding, so you get on topic, or start a new one.
Edit: Once you provide this information I will be happy to dissect it and tell you whats wrong.